Captain Jack’s

Reviews

• Amanda C.

  star star star star star 29 May 2026

  Yes, Captain Jack's lobster rolls are $32.  Are they also bigger than your entire face...YES THEY ARE. Oh and they're absolutely delicious, fresh, and have giant claws within them.  If you are looking to come here with your kids and an affordable meal this may not be your place.  If you are looking to have one (or two) rum buckets, enjoy some great live music by Long Lake, eat some wondrous seafood and have a good time then this is your SPOT.  I love it here.  I do go in knowing I'm going to spend a little bit of moola, and I have accepted that and it is entirely worth it for me.  Rum buckets aren't terribly priced, about $14/15 for a bucket that has about six different rums in it, so yes, a bang for your buck.  
  
  If you're coming here on a weekend, I would get here early if you want a table (5:30 pm or prior) and if you get here later there is some space to stand.  Captain Jack's and Gary's are my two favorite spots in Naples, but this is the only spot for buckets!

• Leigh S.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 18 May 2026

  Coming here during a dinner rush at the end of the summer on a Sunday with two toddlers was our fault. But given the season ending, it was our only feasible option for our group of 6. We waited a long while to be seated, we waited a long long while for our food and we wondered why we bothered.
  
  Our meals were all pretty subpar (or on par with lots of crappy chain restaurants) But the drinks were tasty. It's a large restaurant, so I imagine it is really challenging to manage (in terms of staff, expediting, etc etc) but just the same the staff was pretty unwelcoming and/or uninterested in our party. Unprofessional and too cool for us, specifically.
  
  The decor truly matches the attitude of the hosts and waitstaff here so, If you're wondering if this is your type Of place you'll probably know it as soon as you walk up to it. But If you're tentative about spending your money here, maybe don't!

• Kurt B.

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  Other than being too packed on occasion the place is great!!! Right on the water, music many nights, and delicious meals!!! They make a crab dip that you can't stop eating it's soo good!!! I haven't had a bad meal here!!! Go early if you want to sit and eat!! Service is great whether at a table or the bar!!! Menu has a variety of items... I wouldn't say it's very kid friendly! Great sunsets!

• Queen M.

  star star star star star_border 17 May 2026

  Enjoyed a fabulous lobster roll @ Capt Jacks (expect to pay $$$ but worth the $$$ splurge).   Also enjoyed their wonderful fried clam dinner, but would prefer more clams than onion rings.   Great food, great service at Jacks!

• Larry G.

  star star star star star 9 May 2026

  A hidden jewel. Great food and drinks. Our server Alicia was fantastic, she made our evening.
  Captain Jacks is now our go to place when next in Naples.